When you order a pumpkin spice latte or a caramel macchiato from Starbucks, you likely have an idea of the sugar content.
But what can you anticipate if you opt for a beverage labeled as “sugar-free?”
This is the basis of a proposed class-action lawsuit in the U.S. alleging that the coffee giant misrepresented eight protein drinks as “sugar-free,” despite each containing between 13 and 21 grams of sugar per venti serving due to the natural sugars found in milk.
The lawsuit, submitted on Friday in a federal court in Seattle and reviewed by CBC News, accuses Starbucks of attempting to profit from “the protein craze” and the nutritional trends among consumers.
“By labeling its products ‘Sugar-Free,’ Starbucks makes a specific, measurable claim about these items. Consumers depend on such statements when making purchase decisions,” the lawsuit asserts.
“The 21 grams of sugar in a venti Sugar-Free Caramel Protein Matcha is comparable to five teaspoons of sugar. This is nearly as much sugar as found in a regular Kit Kat bar.”

A screenshot of an Instagram post by Starbucks from October 23, 2025, promoting protein beverages as sugar-free. (@Starbucks/Instagram)
A representative from Starbucks informed CBC News on Wednesday that they believe the allegations in the lawsuit are unfounded.
“Starbucks has always provided clear information regarding its protein beverages, sugar-free alternatives, customization options, and nutritional details … and we plan to defend ourselves robustly,” the spokesperson stated.
So, are these drinks truly sugar-free? Is the labeling deceptive? And does this apply only to U.S. beverages, or is it an issue in Canada as well?
Let’s delve deeper into the lawsuit and what we know so far.
Which drinks are involved?
The lawsuit identifies eight protein beverages that Starbucks markets as sugar-free:
- Sugar-free vanilla protein latte.
- Sugar-free caramel protein latte.
- Sugar-free vanilla protein matcha.
- Sugar-free caramel protein matcha.
- Iced sugar-free vanilla protein latte.
- Iced sugar-free caramel protein latte.
- Iced sugar-free vanilla protein matcha.
- Iced sugar-free caramel protein matcha.
Each drink is featured on both the U.S. and Starbucks Canada websites under the “protein beverages” category. Although the eight items are classified under a “no added sugar options” label, each drink still has “sugar-free” in its name.
Starbucks introduced these beverages in September 2025, citing data indicating that “71 percent of Canadian consumers wish to increase their protein intake.” In a news release at that time, Starbucks stated that its new protein drinks would be “available unsweetened or sugar-free and are intended for customers seeking to add protein to their orders.”
Are these drinks truly sugar-free?
No, each drink contains sugar — ranging from 13 to 21 grams per venti serving. At the higher end, this amount is roughly equivalent to the sugar content found in a Kit Kat or Coffee Crisp chocolate bar, as noted by Health Canada.
When you check the details of each beverage on the company’s website, Starbucks provides nutritional data for every “sugar-free” protein drink, including the sugar content by size. For example, a venti iced sugar-free vanilla protein latte contains 13 grams of sugar, while a venti sugar-free caramel protein matcha has 21 grams of sugar.
The lawsuit highlights that “the sugar-free products all contain milk, which has lactose, a naturally occurring sugar.”
-
Whey up: Protein powder prices soar as global demand grows
-
Is it unprofessional to bring iced coffee to a job interview? Gen Z is being dragged for it
What’s the problem if the sugar is natural?
The concern lies not in the source of the sugar but in the “sugar-free” labeling, according to the lawsuit.
“Even though Starbucks is aware that Sugar-Free products contain milk, which has lactose, and recognizes that lactose is a sugar, it still labels these beverages ‘Sugar-Free,'” the lawsuit claims.
“Starbucks refers to these drinks as ‘Sugar-Free’ because it understands that consumers depend on such claims when making purchasing decisions.”
What consumer protection regulations exist?
U.S. federal regulations prevent Starbucks from labeling a beverage as “sugar-free” if it contains more than 0.5 grams of sugar per 12-ounce serving, as stated in the complaint. This holds true even if the sugar originates from milk.
In Canada, for a product to be classified as sugar-free, it must have less than 0.5 grams of sugars per reference amount and serving size, as per the Food and Drug Regulations.


