It’s 9 p.m. on a Wednesday evening. Are you aware of your children’s whereabouts?
If you happen to be the dramatized version of To Catch a Predator host Chris Hansen, as played by Robert Pattinson in A24’s Primetime, you believe you certainly do — at least, you’ve managed to convince your network that you know where everyone else’s kids are.
This version of Hansen, drink in hand, explains to his seatmate on a plane: this belief is what initially got his show approved. As he tells his network executives, children aren’t out wandering the streets or falling into wells. Instead, they’re isolated in their rooms. Meanwhile, Hansen states, there’s a man loitering on the porch, exposing himself. And in a surprisingly crude description from movie-Hansen that we won’t fully cite: he’s poised to rush into that bedroom.
However, Hansen suggests that if viewers tune into To Catch a Predator tonight on NBC, he will reveal how to prevent such incidents.
The significance of the advice he offers is evident to anyone acquainted with the events of that 2004 series. The Dateline segment featured Hansen emerging from closets and bedrooms to confront suspected child predators lured there by his team — which notoriously resulted in failed legal actions, dangerous imitators, and at least one fatality.
However, Primetime is far from a straightforward critique. The film unfolds as a whirlwind of absurdity and strangeness. It’s a chaotic, spiraling dark comedy. So disconcerting (produced by The Strange Thing About the Johnsons’ Ari Aster, after all) that you won’t be surprised when it juxtaposes casual humor with gut-wrenching horror.
We witness Tony Revolori (Spider-Man: Homecoming) making exaggerated, absurd expressions at the camera alongside images of dismembered children’s bodies left in an unidentified jungle. We observe Pattinson’s Hansen inexplicably spitting mouthwash into a sink — while adopting a stance that resembles less a journalist and more an aggressive goose.
Later, we see this goose-like figure pursuing an actual monster, a representation of the evil that supposedly lurks beyond societal boundaries. Yet, as he continues searching for malevolence outside himself and gazes into the face of wickedness, we are forced to confront his own darkness.
Pattinson delivers a unique, fearless commitment to his role: an apparent inability to feel embarrassment allows him to fully immerse himself in accents, portrayals, and overall absurdity.
In this case, it’s a campy, exaggerated, Spirit Halloween version of Chris Hansen: one who drawls “Why don’t you take a seat” with a deep seriousness that, in anyone else’s portrayal, would come off as utterly ludicrous.

The bizarre and chaotic representation of Chris Hansen in Primetime reveals something new and peculiar about the To Catch a Predator host. (Elevation Pictures)
As suggested by director Lance Oppenheim and writer Ajon Singh, all those exaggerated traits are intended to unveil a profound decay at the core of the real individual. Based on the scathing piece “Tonight on Dateline This Man Will Die,” which discusses a shocking outcome from one of his sting operations, Primetime does not present a favorable view of Hansen’s Dateline series. It reflects criticism — and even court decisions — aimed at the “Creep Catcher” groups that would mimic To Catch a Predator‘s methods, and the screenplay delivers strong and clear condemnations.
This context makes it clear why the actual Chris Hansen has not exactly been supportive of the project.
Instead, he claims to have purchased his own advertisements prior to the film’s release, asserting that the narrative presented is entirely fictional. Similar to how the Church of Latter-day Saints did with the Playbill for The Book of Mormon, he aims to direct audiences towards his own body of work where, according to him, the authentic story lies.
The true-crime streaming network he has established continues to produce content surrounding sexual offenses. A constant flow of new shows follows the format of, and take advantage of audiences’ insatiable hunger for, the public-shaming vigilantism seen in To Catch a Predator.
-
Documentary on aftermath of Windsor, Ont.’s Creeper Hunter to premiere at Toronto’s Hot Docs Festival
-
6 teens charged after string of assaults linked to ‘Catch a Predator’ trend, police say
The critical interpretation of Primetime‘s distorted reflection is apparent. Instead of granting Predator‘s apparently noble objectives any semblance of credit, Oppenheim intentionally seeks to deconstruct Hansen’s presumed self-interest while empathetically portraying his targets.
Through Hansen’s interactions with a frazzled and helpless producer (Merritt Wever), a visibly traumatized and exploited “decoy” actor employed to lure these alleged offenders (Skyler Gisondo), and the sensitively depicted subjects themselves, Primetime‘s message is unmistakable.
Hansen, portrayed as glassy-eyed, vain, and frantic, does not operate Predator as a sacred mission, the film asserts. He does not manipulate local law enforcement to bypass regulations concerning search and seizure, rouse his barely school-aged sons in the middle of the night to witness his latest apprehension, or glare resentfully at NBC reporter Stone Phillips reporting on “real” news due to a sense of altruism.
According to Primetime, his motivation is simple: he craves to be in the spotlight.

Robert Pattinson, right, is featured alongside actor Tony Revolori in a scene from Primetime. (Elevation Pictures)
That alone wouldn’t suffice. The notion that respectability first perished on television is painfully evident; it was insufficient to support the sci-fi critique of capitalism The Running Man last year, and it doesn’t suffice to carry the Rupert Murdoch/Larry Lamb biopic Ink showcased at this year’s TIFF.
Merely recognizing the existential dread surrounding stranger danger that has shaped political agendas and platforms over the past half-century is not sufficient. From the genuinely poignant, loosely inspired adaptation of six-year-old Etan Patz’s disappearance in Without a Trace to the shockingly exploitative child-trafficking film Sound of Freedom, the overwhelming fear regarding the safety of children is clearly a motivating factor.
What Primetime explores is more probing and disturbing. It raises a question not only about self-deception but also about how a lack of compassion appears to be rationalized, even encouraged, in interactions with Hansen’s subjects.
This topic is highlighted by that same airplane companion, who inquires whether Hansen has ever contemplated bypassing the justice system and simply “bleeding” the men he catches.
Hansen considers this proposition, then remarks that perhaps what he is doing is even worse. And then he smiles.
